Science, the Environment and the President(s)

In just a few days we will have a new President. This bodes well for the environment and our nation’s science policies. The outgoing administration has long ignored sound scientific advice to the point of having nonscientists in all the positions of advising the president on science. President-elect Obama has named working scientists to important positions. John Holdren has been appointed director of the Office of White Science and Technology Policy --- Holdren is a Harvard physicist. He will also co-chair the Council of Advisors on Science and Technology Policy with Harold Varmus, former Director of the NIH and Eric Lander, and MIT specialist in the human genome. Appointed to lead the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration is Jane Lubchenco, a well respected marine biologist and former winner of the Audubon Medal for Conservation.

The Bush administration has an 8-year legacy of ignoring the advice of scientists. This has been made clear numerous times with respect to decisions regarding endangered species --- Interior Inspector General Earl Devaney reported in December that Julie MacDonald, former Deputy Assistant Secretary of the Interior did great harm to the department’s integrity and the morale of professionals working to save endangered species, and possible out-right risking the well being of endangered species. She was a civil engineer with no training in the natural sciences. In 2008 she was found to have reversed seven ESA rulings that would have increased protection to specific species. In addition she directly interfered thirteen times with decisions, and influenced.

More recently the Richard Carmona, a former Surgeon General, told Congress that top administration played down public health considerations of global warming due to political considerations [global warming was considered a ‘liberal cause’].

The Bush Administration gave us two last minute presents. One he created 3 Marine National Monuments, extending the protection of eight National Wildlife Refuges and one more site. These sites are widely scattered in remote areas of the pacific. The eight areas that center around existing Fish and Wildlife Service refuge areas are Rose Atoll in American Samoa, Wake Island, Johnston Island, Palmyra Island, Kingman Reef, Baker Island, Howland Island and Jarvis Island. The ninth site is the waters around the northern Marianas and the deepest ocean canyon in the world, the Mariana Trench, 11,033 meters (36,201 feet) at its deepest.

The former is very nice, but his second farewell present is rule change was put into effect that greatly weakens the Endangered Species Act. Environmental advocates say this would make every ESA action a political decision rather than a decision based on the best available science. This rule change would eliminate some mandatory reviews that have been performed on construction and timber sales, and prohibits consideration of the effect of these actions based on the effect of global warming’s effects on endangered species. Bush Interior Secretary Dick Kempthorne said that nothing in the regulation absolves a federal agency of its responsibilities. It might not absolve them, it just would not allow them to use. This rule change will take effect before Obama takes office. Although Obama has said he would reverse this, it will take much longer to do this reverse this because of the rule making procedure.

Hawaii’s birds: the Po’ouli and the ’Akepa: Will We Ever Learn?

My bedtime reading has recently included the Race to Save the World’s Rarest Bird: The Discovery and Death of the Po’ouli by Alvin Powell [Mechanicsburg, PA : Stackpole Books, c2008, viii, 280 p. : map ; 22 cm., Includes bibliographical references and index]. This is a fascinating story of work with an endangered species in some of the worst habitat in the U.S.A. Fascinating and depressing: if the subtitle did not give it away, the book opens with death of a captive Po’ouli. The Po’ouli was unknown to science and apparently natives of Hawai’i until its discovery in July 1973 in the state of Hawai’i’s Hana Forest Reserve on Maui. When initially discovered it was not clear to what family this species belonged. Eventually it was found that his species was one of Hawai’i’s honeycreepers, albeit a species very distantly related to the others.

One would not think that Maui’s with its resorts and beaches could be so miserable, but this is truly one of the most inhospitable places imaginable. This is rainforest so impenetrable that machetes are needed to hack trails, so rainy that researchers are often confined to camp and unable to see anything because of the rain and so cold that researchers caught out of camp needed to huddle together for warmth. At it rained so hard that looking for birds was impossible, confining researchers to tents except for redigging trenches around tent and to take care of things that one did not want to do in your tent.

After its discovery initial estimates of the Po’ouli’s population was estimated in the low hundreds, and it was added to the endangered within two years of its discovery. Feral pigs, goats, rats and Rosy Wolf Snails took a toll. Wolf Snails are introduced predatory snails that eat native snails. One diet items of the Po’ouli are snails. It was clear that the population was crashing. The fact that Po’ouli’s do not sing and their only call is a nondescript chip that sounds like other species made population estimates difficult, especially when coupled with the topography and climate.

The Hawaiian Forest Bird Survey ran from 1976-83 and attempted to identify the distribution and population size of all forest birds on five islands. Population was ca 140, down 80-99% from initial estimates. Pig activity was increasing dramatically. A variety of strategies were thought about: Fencing and removal of feral pigs, establishment of a second population, captive breeding, among others. Fencing was tried first, but the steep, gullied nature of the landscape made it very difficult and hideously expensive. By the time bureaucratic arguments over what permits were needed from what agency were settled it was 1986. Still the population fell. The next survey suggested a population of six [two pair and 2 single birds]. By the time the next year past, both pairs had lost their mates and one single bird disappeared. At this point thoughts turned to relocation. Since the remaining three birds’ territories did not over lap, they would never meet and mate on their own. Captive breeding was viewed as the last resort. Captive breeding has had it successes, but much was unknown about this species and honeycreepers are difficult to breed. Precious little was known about Po’oulis, only one or two nests were ever found and I think only once was an adult observed feeding young. So was decided to relocate individuals from one territory to another in hopes that the birds would meet naturally and breed. One problem with relocation is that many vertebrates are very faithful to their home ranges. Permit issues delayed the start of relocations. Not surprisingly, relocations met with failure as relocated birds returned to their home ranges. Captive breeding was going to be tried. Again permit issues slowed things down. One bird was captured and brought into a place where it was hoped to start captive breeding. The bird sickened, lost weight and died on November 26, 2004. I do not believe a living Po’ouli was seen again. Upon necropsy, this bird appeared to be extremely old.

The book ends on a rather optimistic note, certain that we are better off today than we were 30 years ago to preserve a rare species. People should have learned from the problems and clearly everyone realized that efforts should have started far earlier. Yet I open the November 11 issue of Nature and see ‘Feathers Fly over Hawaiian Bird’, a news/commentary item by Rex Dalton [Nature Vol 456: 682-683]. In this Dalton describes infighting between ornithologists from the University of Hawai’i at Manoa and refuge staff for the Hakalau Forest National Wildlife Refuge on the island of Hawai’i. The ornithologists believe that the ’akepa [yet another threatened Hawaiian Honeycreeper] is undergoing a population crash and suggest that competition with the invasive Japanese White-eye over food is a major factor. Refuge officials believe there is no decline. In published papers Leonard Freed suggests that poor nutrition makes the ’akepa prone to parasites. He suggests that there are only 4000 ’akepa on the refuge and over 20000 Japanese White-eyes. The refuge’s wildlife biologist admits to not even reading the paper.

Will we ever learn?

Notes

A picture and recording of the Po’ouli can be found at
Po’ouli Image and sound recording
and more information at
Po’ouli Facts/

A film of the ’Akepa is at
’Akepa Film
more information is at
’Akepa Factsheet

12 October 2008: Little Known Local Preserves

Today’s trip was to 5 under-appreciated gems in the northern and eastern Johnson County. Every place we visited was north of I-80 and E of the Iowa R. As the sparrow flies they range from ten mile N of Iowa City to 5.5 mile ENE of town. To get to all of them took 60-70 road miles. We did not visit any place for very long, but spent enough time at each to get an idea of what they are like.

N.B. Rather than wrestle w blogger, I wil now post most of my photos at

http://www.pbase.com/xiboia/blog

This blog's photos are at

http://www.pbase.com/xiboia/10_12_08_little_known

We started at two small postage-stamp prairie preserves, above Lake Macbride.

Solon Prairie [3 acre, Johnson County Conservation Commission] has become practically surrounded by Solon. When you look at the sign, you can look across the prairie and see houses. With just walking on the perimeter path, we saw a number of interesting things both. Red-winged Blackbirds were still singing at Solon, and the first warbler of the day, Palm Warbler, was working over some saplings. Prairies this small and ones this close to residential areas are very difficult to manage.

Our next stop was Strub Prairie [1.5 acre, Johnson County Heritage Trust]. Strub was formerly known as Propane Pr as it was by a propane storage tank. We did not see as many birds here, but more interesting plants and butterflies.

The next two places we visited were larger JCHT Preserves that touch the Corps of Engineers lands bordering the Coralville Reservoir. The Big Grove Preserve [40 ac] is one of the remaining portions of the Big Grove described by the first land surveyors in Johnson County. We did not get into the part of this preserve with the more mature trees, still we spent time trying to get good looks at a Winter Wren that was playing mouse in some piles of cut branches. We spent so much time trying unsuccessfully to get a good look at this bird that we decided to move on.

Just short distance away, we visited Turkey Creek Preserve [110 ac]. Although Turkey Creek is mostly woods, we spend our time on the edge of some prairies and some creeks. Many Cedar Waxwings, Yellow-rumped Warblers and Robins and one Hermit Thrush were enjoying some of the berries [Poison Ivy, Virginia Creeper, and others]. A Belted Kingfisher rattled in Turkey Creek.

We finished at Hora Woods [20 ac], a small woodland. We caught the day’s second Hermit Thrush and a few other birds as we dodged the falling walnuts and hickories. A member of the bird club was cutting wood nearby, saw us go past and stopped to visit. He told us that Mrs. Mabel Hora, who donated the property and for whom it is named was his seventh grade math teacher. Preserves so small as this make it almost impossible to avoid seeing the ubiquitous corn or beans.

As we were looking more at the place and less at the birds, our bird list is short -- thirty plus all told.

Solon Prairie: Northern Flicker, Blue Jay, American Crow, American Robin, Cedar Waxwing, Field Sparrow, White-crowned Sparrow, Red-winged Blackbird, Common Grackle, House Finch, and American Goldfinch.

Strub Prairie: Downy Woodpecker, Black-capped Chickadee, House Wren, Palm Warbler, Song Sparrow, Red-winged Blackbird, Common Grackle, and American Goldfinch.

Big Woods: Am White Pelican †, Red-bellied Woodpecker, Northern Flicker, Black-capped Chickadee, Tufted Titmouse, White-breasted Nuthatch, Winter Wren, and Eastern Towhee.

Turkey Creek: Turkey Vulture, Red-tailed Hawk †, Belted Kingfisher, Downy Woodpecker, Northern Flicker, White-breasted Nuthatch, Eastern Bluebird †, Hermit Thrush, American Robin, Cedar Waxwing, Yellow-rumped Warbler, Song Sparrow, Harris's Sparrow, and American Goldfinch.

Hora Woods: Northern Harrier †, American Kestrel †, Peregrine Falcon †, Killdeer †, Downy Woodpecker, Black-capped Chickadee, White-breasted Nuthatch, Hermit Thrush, and American Robin.

Lake Macbride Pelagic Trip, Saturday 4 October 2008

Saturday morning dawned clear and cool, a beautiful mist rising off the still waters of Lake Macbride as I crossed the causeway and headed towards Knight’s Marina. About ten people boarded the Guppy, cast off and headed out onto the lake.

There were a few gulls and possibly a tern flying over the lake but the first birds we got good looks at were a Great Blue Heron perched on a snag coming out of the water and an immature Turkey Vulture sitting on a power line pole, waiting for sunshine and warmer air. Pulling closer to shore we had a few Am. Goldfinches and a couple of birds whose identity was left as Confusing Fall Warbler or Kinglet sp. as they spent most of their time bouncing around in a tree that still had most of its leaves. We also heard Blue Jays, Northern Cardinals and Black-capped Chickadees.

About the time we were finally able to identify one of the gulls as a Ring-billed, the wind picked up a little, and we crossed a small wake and water started to splash over the front of the platform. Water started pouring in and soon a veritable tidal surge swept towards Ed in the back of our brave ship. A minor tussle broke out when lifejackets were ordered for those who could not swim, ‘Where’s my lifejacket?’ Decisive actions by Our Heroic Cap’n soon had the situation under control. By the time we limped into the sailboat dock on the North Arm, water had emptied off the back of the boat. We tied on and exited the boat. It was clear that the boat was floating high and dry although there were some wet feet and one camera was wet.

A number of the group chose not too get back on the our ship and retuned via the White Pine Trail, back to the Cottage Reserve and Our Hosts’ House. We must have looked a little bedraggled as we came out of the woods as several people offered us rides back, ‘Do any of the Titanic Survivors need a lift?’

Our ship’s crew beat the hikers back to the dock. Upon repairing onto Our Hosts’ Four Seasons Room we found that the late arrivals and crew had not even dented the hot coffee and tea, fresh fruit salad, homemade pear bread, egg casserole, and other goodies. Our Heroic Cap’n explained what happened as Simple Physics. Personally I never found Physics as Simple,

On the hike and at Our Hosts’ we added Pileated, Downy and Red-bellied Woodpeckers and a Brown Creeper performed its Anti-Nuthatch Act just off the porch. A junco was seen at Our Hosts’ while we were hiking.